QotW: What’s the most basic car you’re willing to accept?

Today, October 26, is Horseless Carriage Day, marking the date in 1769 when Samuel Johnson, creator of the first complete English dictionary, supposedly learned of a self-propelled coach. Many presume that it was the Cugnot steam-powered buggy, a three-wheeled chassis with a bench and boiler. As automobiles go, you can’t get much simpler than that. These days we expect a bit more from our cars, but Japan is great at delivering minimalist machines that are still fulfilling to drive.

What’s the most basic car you’re willing to accept?

The most entertaining comment by next week will receive a prize. Scroll down to see the winner of last week’s QotW, “How has the landscape for Japanese cars changed in the last 20 years?”

For years Japanese cars struggled to gain respect, but now that they have it, JNCers who have loved these cars for decades feel like things have gotten too expensive. That was the theme in several comments from TheJWT, streetspirit and, we think, Ian G.

Another take is that Japanese brands were once swimming with interesting and diverse products. Now, things have gotten a lot more boring. Taylor C. and daniel lamented the fact that the lineups of once-great marques have gotten quite a bit duller. This weeks winner is Kyuusha Corner, who best encapsulated this notion:

It has gotten significantly worse. What car is actually lust-worthy? What car will become as legendary as the cars of the 20 years prior to the last 20? The only car in the last 20 years that I feel isn’t depressingly bad is the Honda Fit (I haven’t driven a newer Miata, though). The last 20 years has been a depressing downward spiral where cars are getting worse and worse due to manufacturers not innovating around the (frankly anti-consumer, anti-driver) regulations, and everyone trying to build cars around, and compete on, features and tech. Car reviewers rarely shine a light on this problem as they tend to compare current cars among each other. They never compare them with the greats of the past to see if there has been improvement. It’s usually “these 1 or 2 models are the best drivers cars on the market for reasons because they have the best steering feel, best engine, etc.” But, what about the cars that came before? Why is the steering feel worse, and why do we accept that? Why are the engines not as engaging and why do we not call it out?

With the current trajectory in the landscape for Japanese cars, there isn’t a single car I could bring myself to spend money on – and not a single car that stirs the soul, so I don’t anticipate ever buying a new car. If I started a car company, I would want to make cars where we ask questions such as: Does it eagerly dance with it’s driver? How does it feel to interact with the switches and dials? Does it communicate everything to the driver in a way that delights? How few are the pain points when maintaining or repairing it?

Omedetou, your comment has earned you a set of decals from the JNC Shop!

JNC Decal smash

permalink.
This post is filed under: Question of the Week and
tagged: .

14 Responses to QotW: What’s the most basic car you’re willing to accept?

  1. Klaus Kopernikus says:

    The Toyota Probox would be the most basic car for me. I need a vehicle that looks like it delivers office supplies but drives like someone’s getting fired if the package arrives late. No fancy screens, no unnecessary buttons, just pure Japanese engineering and a driver who has 47 deliveries left before 5 PM.

  2. dankan says:

    Living in Ottawa, I need heated seats and AC. I also need a back seat for the dog. Beyond that, I don’t really “need” anything. It doesn’t have to be fast, it doesn’t need to be beautiful, it just needs to get the job done. I find cheap cars more interesting in general as it’s a lot more engineering work to give them character and good driving characteristics since there are no fat tires and big horsepower to save you.

  3. TheJWT says:

    For a daily I don’t think I could live without heated seats and bluetooth. I don’t care about android auto/carplay, I just want to be able to listen to my music without an aux cord.

    For a fun car (and depending on the car), carbed, manual steering, roll-up windows, steel wheels

  4. BlitzPig says:

    At least in the American market, there are no “basic” cars anymore.
    Every car out there has power windows, AC, power steering, automatic trans as standard, power locks, heated seats, ABS, and a screen or two. Modern drivers have never experienced a window crank, or a car with no radio, and certainly never a car without an automatic.

    I feel sorry for those that have never driven a Lotus 7, or a Morgan +4, but in the end what would it matter? Most people would hate those cars anyway…

  5. ra21benj says:

    The most basic car I’m willing to accept would be like the 4th gen Honda Civic (EF). Around 2,000 lbs, 1.6-liter EFI twin cam engine with throttle cable, manual steering, manual windows & locks, air con. & heater, 4-wheel disk brakes with no ABS/traction control, stock 14 inch wheels, and FM stereo with CD player.

  6. @ye says:

    Miata is always the answer

  7. Negishi no Keibajo says:

    If we were able to have the JDM electric Scion iQ, we would have kept it. We finally had to replace with a Bolt…waiting for a Slate.

  8. I’m a simple guy who’s fine with a pretty basic car. That said, I would like to shoot for something repairable and easy to maintain with a roof and A/C!

    Will pay more for luxuries such as hand crank windows, a manual transmission, and hydraulic or manual steering.

  9. エーイダン says:

    Ford Japanese: 1993 Toyota Camry. For elsewhere: Lada Niva/Vaz 2121. Both are pretty much indestructible, they are the epitome of basic.

  10. streetspirit says:

    I don’t really care for luxury like electric windows and considering i’m always cold AC is just extra weight. that being said, since my shop produces 270mm and 190mm steering wheels i might…slightly….maybe have grown fond of power steering.

  11. Jeff says:

    If you’re speaking in the most basic sense, you might be referring to a kei car in terms of size. But that doesn’t mean it has to be boring.
    Recently, I had the opportunity to put a couple hundred miles on a Honda City Turbo, a remarkably daring entry into the market for its time. It packed all sorts of unusual features, a lively engine (“Hyper Turbo” as the rear window decal proclaims in very large letters), and plenty of character, while still remaining basic and economical. Think roll-up windows rather than what passed for luxury equipment in the early 1980s. And that’s before even mentioning the very cool and absolutely unique Motocompo.
    The modern equivalent would be the Honda Super-One / Super EV Concept, assuming it makes it into production. It’s another kei car, reimagined as a spiritual successor to the City Turbo, with the same emphasis on agility, lightness, and fun rather than outright speed.
    Speaking of the City Turbo as an example, what a fun car it is to drive. The only real disappointment is the shifter. It lacks the precise shifter linkage geometry of modern transverse-engined Hondas, whose manual transmission shifters are the best in the business. After all, can you imagine a Civic Type R with a slow or vague shifter?
    Among Honda’s greatest hits, however, the shifter in the longitudinally architected, rear-wheel-drive S2000 remains the benchmark for shift quality and precision. Pulling ours out of the garage recently for a long-overdue backroads drive reminded me why. A great shifter encourages you to make the most of an engine, all 9,000 RPM of it in the S2000’s case. That is where the City Turbo most clearly reveals the age of its design. You can’t shift it cleanly or quickly enough to keep pace with what the engine can do.
    Setting that aside, the Honda City Turbo remains a great but basic car. The project was championed by Soichiro Honda’s son, and it is easy to imagine his famous father smiling at the result. It is an honest, lightweight, genuinely enjoyable and basic machine, filled with clever features and just enough character (with Honda’s first passenger car production turbocharged engine) to make it memorable. If Honda built a true modern equivalent today, Motocompo not needed, I’d happily have one in my garage.

  12. Joe Musashi says:

    Basic? From my perspective, I would choose something like the Del Sol, an EG, or an EK Honda only because I find those cars fascinating and simple to work on.
    I still would like my powered windows, climate, and all the amenities that come with a “nice car”.

  13. Jonathan P. says:

    Basic car? Something with:
    4 cyl. (willing to go with three if it’s a Geo),
    Heat and A/C, you can’t live down South without it, well, you can, but you don’t want to. I did that for three years. Shoulda took care of that after the first year.
    FM Radio, AUX optional,
    Manual transmission,
    manual windows,
    15-inch or smaller tires,
    There’s a lot of JNC’s that match this description, I have no doubt, but as far as picking a specific model, I fear I am at a loss of thought.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *